It's very difficult to say what's the best mobile device in a given year, because different people have different needs and desires. The ideal device for me might be repulsive to you, and vice-versa. But most of the computer publications try to make a call anyway. If you read the end-of-year reviews online, you'll probably conclude that the best mobile product of the year was the iPhone. It was cited by the Washington Post, Wired, Business Week, and Tech Republic (which strangely listed it as a business technology product, alongside Salesforce.com and LinkedIn).
Other mobile products getting mentions from major publications included the Nokia n95, iPod Touch, Razr 2, and Blackberry 8800. Amazon's Kindle was the only one that showed up on both best-of and worst-of lists. The best-ofs generally liked the wireless features and screen, while the worst-ofs disliked the closed business model and "eye-poking" industrial design.
I don't agree with any of those choices.
Since people have different needs, I think the best product of the year ought to be the one that best meets needs the needs of a particular group of users. It should be utterly compelling to its own audience. There are several questions to ask:
How efficient is it? Since people use mobile devices on the go, it should do just what the user needs, without any confusion or unneeded features. But there can't be any critical features missing, either.
How well does it trade off size vs. power? Because it's carried on your person, where size and weight are at a premium, it should balance tiny size with reasonable battery life.
How does it look? Because it's effectively a part of your wardrobe, it must look great (or whatever the target customer thinks of as great).
By that standard, I think the best mobile device of 2007 -- in fact, one of the best mobile products of all time -- was the third generation iPod Nano.
Don't get me wrong, iPhone fans. The iPhone is a very interesting and provocative device. There are some beautiful features in the user interface, and I love the turmoil it's causing in the industry. Several years from now we may look back on it and call it the most influential mobile device of its time. But that doesn't mean it's the best product.
To me, the iPhone is more an intriguing statement of direction than a completed product at this point. The lack of 3G is a huge compromise, and Apple obviously didn't think through the third party application thing. If you want a slow mobile browser that also plays music and videos and doubles as a somewhat awkward phone, then the iPhone is great. But for all of the cool highlights in the iPhone, I don't think it's enough to crush the phone industry in its current version. Future versions, maybe. We'll shortlist the iPhone III for product of the year in 2010.
The n95 is also a remarkable product in its own way, and I know it inspires a lot of technolust, especially in Europe. But in my opinion, it's just the latest Swiss Army Knife of the mobile world. Next year there will be another one from Nokia or Samsung or somebody else that has an even higher-resolution camera or maybe an electric toothpick or something, and people will be fawning all over that one. Like a lot of Japanese consumer electronics products, it's not a marvelous product as much as it is a marvelously ingenious bag of features.
By contrast, in third generation Nano is not just the latest model from Apple, it's an elegant culmination of the design work they've been doing for years.
The Nano doesn't look all that great in photographs. It's wider than its predecessor, which produced some criticism when it was announced (Engadget nicknamed it "fatty," which is asinine when you see it in person). In real life, the Nano's shape is compelling. It's much thinner than you'd expect from the pictures -- shockingly thin for something that has a color screen and plays videos. With its heavily rounded corners and brightly colored case, it feels a bit like a high tech chocolate wafer. You're almost tempted to take a bite out of it.
Physically, the Nano is almost all user interface -- the screen and thumbwheel take up the entire front of the device. Until we get flexible screens, the Nano is about as small as you can possibly make a device with its features. This is the endpoint, a form factor that's going to be with us for a while.
The biggest surprise to me about the Nano is the usability of video on it. When it was announced, I thought video was a throwaway feature -- who would ever want to watch video on a screen that small? But the reality is that when you're sitting down, you'll hold a Nano about 18 inches (45 cm) away from your face. At that distance, the screen is about the same apparent size as a 20-inch television (50 cm) at the other side of the living room. It's not like watching a flat panel monster screen, but it's very usable.
I'm not sure yet how much video will be used on the device, or what sorts of video, but that's a general question about mobile video rather than anything specific about the Nano. What I've observed so far is teenage girls using the Nano to watch music videos together, commenting on how cute the drummer is.
And that's just another sign that Apple made a great design for its target audience.
The new Nano doesn't have Bluetooth built into it, or Wi-Fi, or a camera, or a phone, or a hard drive. That probably accounts for why the technophiles online have been so dismissive of it (link). But to me, it's an almost perfect balance of functionality and art. Come back in ten or twenty years and I think you'll find it in design museums, when most of today's mobile devices will be long-forgotten and mildly embarrassing.
What do you think? Do you agree with my choice? If not, what do you think was the best mobile device of 2007?
Mobile Device of the Year, 2007
Mobile Device of the Year, 2007 - we say welcome to you who have been searching for information via search engines such as Google, in a blog Tech Gallery, now we will discuss information about the Mobile Device of the Year, 2007, we have been looking for a lot of information from a trusted and collect it in this blog, so you get the information complete and easy to understand, please read through:
Article Apple, Article Blackberry, Article iPhone, Article Kindle, Article nano, Article Nokia, Article RIM,
Article Apple, Article Blackberry, Article iPhone, Article Kindle, Article nano, Article Nokia, Article RIM,
You can also see our article on:
- How To Choose The Right eBook Reader and Software for Reading Digital Books
- Will E-Readers Eat the Tablet Computer?
- Is Apple too powerful?
- Mobile Device of the Year, 2007
- Nokia phone is all set for revival
- Microsoft Lumia 950 (Dual SIM) Price in Nigeria and Review
- Quick Takes: The RIM Tragedy, Lame Market Research, Ebooks Closer to Tipping, Flip vs. Cisco, Google as Microsoft, Nokia and the Word "Primary"
- RIM's Q3 Financials: A Tale of Two BlackBerries
- ChIPs Global Summit Report 4: Facebook, Apple and the DoJ discuss the tension between privacy and security
- Hidden Features of iOS 9 that Apple Didn’t Talk About
- BlackBerry Storm 2 9550 Price & Feartures
- BlackBerry Pearl Flip 8220 Price & Features
- iPhone New iOS 8.3 FIrmware Free Download iclarified
- How to make more sotrage-space in your iPhone
Information about the Mobile Device of the Year, 2007 we have conveyed
A few of our information about the Mobile Device of the Year, 2007, I hope you can exploit carefully
You have finished reading Mobile Device of the Year, 2007 and many articles about Tech Gallery in our blog this, please read it. and url link of this article is https://littlebitjohnny.blogspot.com/2008/01/mobile-device-of-year-2007.html Hopefully discussion articles on provide more knowledge about the world of new tech gadgets.
Tag : Apple, Blackberry, iPhone, Kindle, nano, Nokia, RIM,
Related : Mobile Device of the Year, 2007
Download Kijamii- New Twitter Apps for BlackberryYou get bored with Social Scope Twitter app, or Twitter UberSocial for BlackBerry? You want to find a simple Twitter app but brings the menus complete Twitter? Maybe you ...
The phones and the iMac of Kim Jong-unLast week, North Korea said that it entered a "state of war" with neighboring South Korea. According to a report from the state-run Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) thi ...
Is Symbian dead? And if so, who killed it?"We should declare victory and go home." --Apocryphal quote attributed to George David AikenI hesitate to write anything about Symbian, because it's a great way to ge ...
Samsung, Nokia, Symphony Display and Smart Phone, iPhone, iPad, iPod Touch Screen Problem Samsung, Nokia, Symphony Display and Smart Phone, iPhone, iPad, iPod Touch Screen ProblemSamsung, Nokia, Symphony Display and Smart Phone, iPhone, iPad, iPod &nbs ...
The OS is always greener...In a report from a developer meeting, Nokia officials said they're moving to Maemo Linux as the OS for their high-end smartphones. That resulted in an entertaining litt ...
- How To Choose The Right eBook Reader and Software for Reading Digital Books
- Will E-Readers Eat the Tablet Computer?
- Is Apple too powerful?
- Mobile Device of the Year, 2007
- Nokia phone is all set for revival
- Microsoft Lumia 950 (Dual SIM) Price in Nigeria and Review
- Quick Takes: The RIM Tragedy, Lame Market Research, Ebooks Closer to Tipping, Flip vs. Cisco, Google as Microsoft, Nokia and the Word "Primary"
- RIM's Q3 Financials: A Tale of Two BlackBerries
- ChIPs Global Summit Report 4: Facebook, Apple and the DoJ discuss the tension between privacy and security
- Hidden Features of iOS 9 that Apple Didn’t Talk About
- BlackBerry Storm 2 9550 Price & Feartures
- BlackBerry Pearl Flip 8220 Price & Features
- iPhone New iOS 8.3 FIrmware Free Download iclarified
- How to make more sotrage-space in your iPhone
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment