The grounds for the German Federal Court of Justice's decision in the Sparkassen Group/Banco Santander dispute over the validity of Sparkassen's colour mark "red" (HSK 13) for financial services, namely retail banking, have been published last week. The 46-page judgment takes a very close look at the proper methodology of consumer surveys designed to prove acquired distinctiveness. Since no less than four surveys were submitted by the parties, two by each side, the Court had a wealth of material to work with.
|
Red. |
If you are not familiar with the background of the dispute, have a look at our
earlier post on the decision. Essentially, Banco Santander applied for a declaration of invalidity for lack of (acquired) distinctiveness of Sparkassen's colour mark, was unsuccessful before the German IPO, successful before the Federal Patent Court and ultimately unsuccessful before the Bundesgerichtshof, which confirmed the validity of the mark. The case led to a referral to the CJEU, which was answered in the joined cases
C‑217/13 and C‑218/13 in 2014 (see
summary by Birgit Clark on IPKat).
Given the length of the decision, I can only highlight a few points in the following. The decision will be the reference case for the design of consumer surveys for proof of acquired distinctiveness for years to come.
The
IPSOS survey from 2006 showed the participants a red card and opened with the following question:
Have you ever seen this colour in connection with financial institutions, or does it appear familiar in this context? Or have you never encountered this colour in connection with financial institutions?
According to the BGH, this question was suggestive, as it already created a link to a certain kind of companies, namely financial institutions. It already introduced the key question - whether the sign was understood as reference to a single entity - into the first question, which should only filter for persons that have never encountered the sign (para. 43). The proper way was to ask whether the respondents had seen the colour in connection with the claimed
products.
A further "grave flaw" of the IPSOS survey was counting those respondents that said that they had never encountered the sign among the 66% of respondents that associated the sign with the Sparkassen Group. Those respondents who do not recall ever having seen the sign must be counted among those who do not perceive the sign as an indication of source (para. 45). The
Pflüger survey submitted by Sparkassen Group in 2013 was not able to correct the deficiencies of the IPSOS survey from 2006. Surveys conducted several years after the relevant date - here the trade mark owner tried to prove acquired distinctiveness at the time of filing in 2002 - could only be considered if the market conditions were stable over longer periods of time, which was not established here (para. 50).
|
Too much paper... |
Another flaw of the Pflüger survey - which equally applies to the IPSOS survey - was that the first question asked "Have you ever seen this colour in connection with financial services [as listed]
or does it appear familiar in this context? Or have you never encountered this colour in this context?" According to the Court, the part of the question here put in italics is impermissible, as it leads respondents to consider a third answer, other than yes or no, to the question. It was fine to count those who
spontaneously answered that the colour appeared familiar among those who know the sign, but "looks familiar" must not be an explicit option, as it leads to inflated figures (para. 72. In the case at hand, only about 17% of respondents spontaneously answer that the colour seems familiar, but 24% if explicitly given the option).
The Court addressed, but left deliberately open, the allocation of the burden of proof. According to German case law, if
lack of acquired distinctiveness at the time of filing cannot be established, the validity of the mark is confirmed, so the burden of proof lies with the nullity plaintiff. According to the CJEU's judgment in cases C-217/13 and C-218/13, the opposite is true - the burden of proof for acquired distinctiveness lies with the trade mark owner (
there at para. 68). The BGH did not have to decide the issue - it hints that it is unhappy with the CJEU's finding - because it found that the evidence on record established that the mark had acquired distinctiveness at the time of the Federal Patent Court's decision in 2015. Because Germany exercised the option under Article 3(3) second sentence
Directive 2008/95, proof of acquired distinctiveness either at the time of filing or at the time of decision leads to validity of the mark (§
8(3) German Trade Mark Act).
The respondents in the Pflüger survey answered the second question as follows:
In connection with financial services...
- the colour refers to ("hinweisen") a specific financial institution (63%)
- the colour refers to several financial institutions (8%)
- the colour does not refer to any financial institution (4%)
- cannot answer (6%)
This question was appropriate (para. 79). 62% of respondents named a company of the trade mark owner's group in answer to the third question "Do you know the name of this financial instution?".
Overall, the Bundesgerichtshof considered that the survey, flawed as it was, proved that more than 50% of the relevant consumers perceived the colour as a reference to a specific financial institution, i.e. as distinctive. Although the Court repeats the old "there cannot be fixed percentage values as absolute limits" (para. 92), it is pretty clear that anything above 50% is enough (para. 109).
Also interesting is what the Court did
not address with a single word - whether it is enough that the consumers
perceive the colour as a reference to a single entity, or whether it must be demonstrated that they
rely on the mark when choosing the product. As you may recall, Arnold J in his second KitKat decision (
IPKat post) held that "the applicant or trade mark proprietor must prove that, at the relevant date, a significant proportion of the relevant class of persons perceives the relevant goods or services as originating from a particular undertaking
because of the sign in question" (
there at para. 57) and considered the survey evidence submitted by Nestlé, structurally very similar to the evidence before the Federal Court of Justice, to be inadequate to answer this question. Since the briefs are not on public record in Germany, it is unclear whether the nullity plaintiff even raised the issue. In any case, German Courts do not seem to be inclined to follow Arnold J's lead (for a critical take on the KitKat decision, see my
recent piece in ABA's Landslide Magazine).
The watch is designed and functionally sober and elegant. Top Quality Replica Rolex UK The quality is relatively perfect. This is the first time I bought a copy watch. This watch is very surprising to me. The color is very low-key,Perfect Replica rolex air-king watches looks very lady, gave the girlfriend one, the girlfriend has always praised this watch in front of me, she is very happy.
ReplyDeletebansdroni Escorts
ReplyDeletebansdroni Escort
bansdroni Escort Service
bansdroni Call Girls
bansdroni Independent Escorts
barrackpore Escort
barrackpore Escorts
barrackpore Escort service
barrackpore call girls
barrackpore independent Escorts
behala Escorts
behala Escort service
behala call girls
behala Escort
behala independent Escorts
belgachia Escorts
belgachia Escort
belgachia Escort service
belgachia call girls
belgachia independent Escorts
Kolkata Escort
ReplyDeleteKolkata Escorts
Kolkata Escort Service
Kolkata Model Escort
Kolkata Female Escort
Kolkata Hotel Escort
Kolkata Call Girls
Kolkata Indeepndent Escorts
Kolkata Vip Escort
Kolkata Sexy Escort
salt lake escorts
salt lake escort
Kolkata Russian Escorts
Kolkata Russian Escort
Amazing! It’s nice I appreciate your website. Working at Nursing Assignment Help, I just got time today for searching and I got your blog and it makes me fresh. Thanks
ReplyDeleteERP Software for distributors
ReplyDeletebritish shorthair cat
ReplyDeleteBritish shorthair kittens
British shorthair kittens for sale
British shorthair kittens for sale near me
British shorthair kittens for adoption
british shorthair gold
british shorthair blue
british shorthair golden
british shorthair for adoption
british shorthair white
british shorthair personalities
british shorthair shedding
british shorthair black
british shorthair tabby
british shorthair don't
british shorthair for sale near me
british shorthair grey
british shorthair breeders near me
british shorthair cost
british shorthair lilac
british shorthair orange
british shorthair white cat
british shorthair silver shaded
british shorthair temperament
ReplyDeleteBritish shorthair kittens for sale near me
British shorthair kittens for sale
British shorthair kittens
british shorthair brown
british shorthair size
british shorthair rescue california
british shorthair red
british shorthair white kitten
british shorthair white and grey
british shorthair weight
british shorthair fat
british shorthair colors
ReplyDeleteBritish shorthair kittens
British shorthair kittens for sale
British shorthair kittens for sale near me
British shorthair kittens for adoption
british shorthair silver tabby
british shorthair kittens nj
british shorthair munchkin
british shorthair gray
british shorthair chinchilla
british shorthair los angeles
british shorthair near me
british shorthair blue eyes
british shorthair with blue eyes
british shorthair domestic cat
british,shorthair vs russian blue
british shorthair kittens nyc
british shorthair mix
british shorthair scottish fold
ReplyDeletebritish shorthair temperament
British shorthair kittens for sale near me
British shorthair kittens for sale
British shorthair kittens
british shorthair brown
british shorthair size
british shorthair rescue california
british shorthair red
british shorthair white kitten
british shorthair white and grey
british shorthair weight
british shorthair fat
british shorthair vs american shorthair
ReplyDeleteare british shorthair cats hypoallergenic
british shorthair new york
british shorthair allergies
british,shorthair golden chinchilla
do british shorthair cats shed
british shorthair tuxedo
british shorthair exotic
british shorthair male
are british shorthair hypoallergenic
british shorthair vs scottish fold
how much do british shorthair cats cost
british shorthair utah
british shorthair lilac kitten
british shorthair for sale
ReplyDeletebritish shorthair for sale near me
british shorthair kittens for sale florida
british shorthair for sale texas
british shorthair for sale california
british shorthair for sale nyc
british shorthair for sale florida
british shorthair for sale mn
british shorthair for sale craigslist
british shorthair kittens for sale houston tx
british shorthair for sale in los angeles
british shorthair for sale san francisco
british shorthair for sale indiana
british shorthair for sale
buy a british shorthair canada
british shorthair for sale
ReplyDeletebritish shorthair for sale near me
british shorthair kittens for sale florida
british shorthair for sale texas
british shorthair for sale california
british shorthair for sale nyc
british shorthair for sale florida
british shorthair for sale mn
british shorthair for sale craigslist
british shorthair kittens for sale houston tx
british shorthair for sale in los angeles
british shorthair for sale san francisco
british shorthair for sale indiana
british shorthair for sale
buy a british shorthair canada
buy british shorthair
ReplyDeletebuy british shorthair cat
buy a british shorthair kitten
where to buy british shorthair kittens
where can i buy a british shorthair kitten
buy british shorthair kitten usa,cheap british shorthair kittens
buy british blue shorthair kitten
buy british shorthair cat london
buy british shorthair kitten london
buy british shorthair london
buy british shorthair melbourne
buy british blue shorthair cat
buy british shorthair blue
British shorthair kittens for adoption
Great and nice information. We are the Home appliance repair Dubai company and give best service of Home appliance repair in Dubai Abu Dhabi
ReplyDeleteHOT CALL GIRL IN KOLKATA
ReplyDeleteWHATSAPP NUMBERS OF GIRLS
INDIAN FEMALE ESCORT
TOP 10 SEXY GIRL
KOLKATA FEMALE FRIENDSHIP
ESCORTS WEBSITES
GIRLFRIEND ON RENT IN INDIA
SEX GIRLS WHATSAPP NUMBER
GIRLS IN KOLKATA FOR SEX
GET GIRLS WHATSAPP NUMBER
KOLKATA TO SONAGACHI
WHO ARE CALL GIRL
INDIAN SEX GIRL MOBILE NUMBER
HOTELS AT BARRACKPORE
MASSAGE IN KOLKATA PARK STREET
WHATSAPP GIRL NAMBAR
GOA SLUTS
HYDERABAD SEX WORKER
CALL OF GIRL
LOCAL CALL GIRLS COM
PROSTITUTE CENTRE IN KOLKATA
ONLINE GIRLS BOOKING
INDIAN TRANNY ESCORTS
ONLINE DATING SITE IN KOLKATA
HOT GIRL.IN
SEXY MODELS NAMES
CALLGIRL IN KOLKATA
WHATSAPP GIRLS CONTACT
MODEL GIRL IMAGES
HYDERABAD SEX PLACES
SONAGACHI KOLKATA PHOTO
BEAUTIFUL GIRL MOBILE NUMBER
ESCORT GIRL SEX
ESCORT SERVICE WEBSITE
HOT LADIES NUMBER
INDIAN CALL GIRL WHATSAPP NO
BODY MASSAGE IN KOLKATA HOME SERVICE
INDIAN GIRLS MODELS
ONLINE CALLGIRLS
REAL CALL GIRLS
ReplyDeleteESCORT MEANING IN BENGALI
MADHYAMGRAM B.ED. COLLEGE
MALE ESCORT MEANING IN HINDI
CALL GIRL IN DELHI WITH MOBILE NO AND PHOTO
ESCORTS SITES
WWW ESCORTS
KOLKATA LOCANTO CALL GIRL
SEXY GIRL OF THE WORLD
SONAGACHI GIRL CONTACT NUMBER
SEXY GIRLS WHATSAPP NUMBER
SONAGACHI KOLKATA ADDRESS
MUMBAI SONAGACHI
CALL GIRL SEX YOUTUBE
VIDHI SERIAL ACTRESS
DUM DUM TO HOWRAH
INDIAN SEXY GIRL PHONE NUMBER
NEARBY GIRLS WHATSAPP NUMBER
KOLKATA HOUSEWIFE SEX VIDEO
SONAGACHI KI PHOTO
WORLD TOP 10 HOT GIRL
GIRLS TOP IMAGE
PRIYA HOTEL
GIRL MODEL IMAGES
VERY HOT GIRL PIC
ESCORTS SERVICE INDIA
FEMALE ESCORT SERVICE IN KOLKATA
FAME NATIONAL ONLINE BOOKING
KOLKATA FREE SEX
INDIAN GIRLS PHONE NUMBER
HOT FEMALE MODELS
SEX CALL APP
PROSTITUTION IN KOLKATA HOTELS
BANGALORE PUBS LADIES NIGHT
HOT NAMES FOR GIRLS
SHEMALE ESCORTS KOLKATA
RANDI KHANA IN KOLKATA
I think I know the app that can come in handy. It's from mspy.com - a really efficient phone tracking tool. if you need to spy on your husband or make sure your kids are safe, you may just install this program on their devices.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.caviargoldweed.com/
ReplyDeletehttps://www.caviargoldweed.com/product/caviar-silver/
https://www.caviargoldweed.com/product/la-kush-cake/
https://www.caviargoldweed.com/product/wifi-cake/
https://www.caviargoldweed.com/product/wedding-pie/
https://www.caviargoldweed.com/product/sour-apple-strain/
https://www.oxycodonehcl.com/
ReplyDeletehttps://www.oxycodonehcl.com/product/buy-oxycodone-online/
https://www.oxycodonehcl.com/product/actavis-cough-syrup/
https://www.oxycodonehcl.com/product/buy-adderall-online/
https://www.oxycodonehcl.com/product/buy-ketamine-powder/
https://www.oxycodonehcl.com/product/buy-research-chemicals-in-china-buy-sodium-
cyanideonlinesodium-cyanide-for-euthanasia/
ReplyDeleteOUTCALL INDEPENDENT ESCORTS
OUTCALL INDEPENDENT ESCORT
OUTCALL ESCORTS
OUTCALL ESCORT
OUTCALL CALL GIRLS
OUTCALL CALL GIRL
AIRHOSTESS ESCORTS
AIRHOSTESS ESCORT
AIRHOSTESS ESCORTS SERVICE
AIRHOSTESS ESCORT SERVICE
AIRHOSTESS INDEPENDENT ESCORTS
AIRHOSTESS INDEEPNDENT ESCORT
AIRHOSTESS CALL GIRLS
AIRHOSTESS CALL GIRL
BARABAZAR ESCORTS
BARABAZAR ESCORT
BARABAZAR ESCORTS SERVICE
BARABAZAR ESCORT SERVICE
BARABAZAR CALL GIRLS
BARABAZAR CALL GIRL
BARABAZAR INDEPEDNENT ESCORTS
BARABAZAR INDEPENDENT ESCORTS
MEANING OF CARESS IN HINDI
ReplyDeleteCALL GIRLS IN KOLKATTA
THAI ESCORT SERVICE
LARICA INN MUMBAI
MUMBAI ESCORT AGENCY
MUMBAI CALL GIRL PHONE NUMBER
ONLINE GIRLS MOBILE NO
MUMBAI GIRLS MOBILE NUMBER FOR FRIENDSHIP
US CALL GIRLS
SEX IN CALCUTTA
CALCUTTA ESCORTS
GIRLS WHATSAPP NUMBER NEAR YOU
SCOT SERVICE IN MUMBAI
GIRL NO ON WHATSAPP
ESCORT FACILITY
HOT GIRL PHOTO FACEBOOK
WHATSAPP NUMBER SEXY GIRL
MALE ESCORTS MUMBAI
WHATS APP NUMBER OF RANDI
GIRLS SEX PHONE NUMBER
HOW TO CALL A CALL GIRL
MUMBAI SEX AREA
MUMBAI RANDI MOBILE NUMBER
FEMALE MODELS IN MUMBAI
INDEPENDENT ESCORTS INDIA
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteHow Can You Update Xbox One Controller Firm Ware
Tips on How to Start an Internet Business
ReplyDeleteDeveloping Your Small Business Marketing Plan
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeletebuy-nclex-license-online
buy-pmp-c
this is Epson printer error code E-01 and epson printer error e-01
ReplyDeletethis is Epson printer error code 0xea and epson error code 0xea
this is Epson printer error code 0x10 and epson printer error 0x10
this is epson printer error code 0xe5 and epson printer error 0xe5
-------------------
this is epson printer error code W-12 and epson w-12 error
ReplyDeleteMobile App Developers
Mobile App Development
Web Design
House Cleaning Charlotte
Commercial Office Cleaning
Residential Cleaning Charlotte
I have been on the internet lately, looking for something to read and that is how I came across your site and saw this article of yours. So, I decided to see what it says and I find out that it is so amazing. You really did great work on your site and the articles you posted on it. You really take your time in writing this article and they are clearly detailed. For more such articles please check Fragment Based Drug Discovery,Glycosylation Analysis,Thermostable Vaccines,Artificial Intelligence
ReplyDeleteEurope Biodiesel Market Report and Forecast 2022-2027’, gives an in-depth analysis of the Europe Biodiesel Market, assessing the market based on its segments like feedstocks, types, technologies, applications, and major regions. The report tracks the latest trends in the industry and studies their impact on the overall market. It also assesses the market dynamics, covering the key demand and price indicators, along with analyzing the market based on the SWOT and Porter’s Five Forces models. The limited supply can be associated with factors like the advent of COVID-19 pandemic, which led to disruptions in supply chain and hampered imports and exports. Furthermore, Argentina is considered as one of the major suppliers of soybean in Europe but due to changes in production and consumption patterns of soybean, the market witnessed a decline.
ReplyDeleteIf you wish to see more reports check here: Asia Pacific Vaccine Market, Micro Inverter Market, Albumin Market, Middle East and Africa Cybersecurity Market, Rice Seeds Market, Vegetable Concentrates Market, Learning Management System Market, States Flooring Market, Sports and Energy Drinks Market, Brazil Healthcare, Sterilisation Services Market, Media Monitoring Tools Market
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteBecause of the extensive use and promotion of the mark, consumers now directly associate the mark with the applicant as the source of those goods. Sinuano Noche Resultados 2023 Note: Long-term use alone is generally not sufficient to show acquired distinctiveness for marks that are merely ornamental.
ReplyDelete